I have never had The Elf on the Shelf. Frankly, it's creepy as hell. I decided to find out exactly what it's about, so I checked elfontheshelf.com...
"The Elf on the Shelf® is a special scout elf sent from the North Pole to help Santa Claus manage his naughty and nice lists. When a family adopts an elf and gives it a name, the elf receives its Christmas magic and can fly to the North Pole each night to tell Santa Claus about all of the day's adventures. Each morning, the elf returns to its family and perches in a different place to watch the fun. Children love to wake up and race around the house looking for their elf each morning. There are two simple rules that every child knows when it comes to having an elf. First, an elf cannot be touched; Christmas magic is very fragile and if an elf is touched it may lose that magic and be unable to fly back to the North Pole. Second, an elf cannot speak or move while anyone in the house is awake! An elf's job is to watch and listen."
So basically your kid is being told that this creepy ass doll is there to stare at them. Then it reports what you do to the guy who makes the naughty or nice list. It's a spy and a rat. It was bad enough when your parents said "if you're not good Santa will know". Now we have "if you're not good the damn elf will go running to the North Pole to tell Santa because he's too lazy to watch you himself".
Kids are encouraged to talk to their elves, especially to share secrets. The more the kids share, the more the elf can learn more about them. Telling the elf secrets seems to secure a space on the nice list. And, it gives parents a place to put a voice-activated tape recorder to find out who really broke Mom's lamp.
And have you ever looked closely at the Elf on the Shelf? His eyes seem to watch you. Or hers. Sorry, didn't mean to be sexist. They are available as either boy elves or girl elves. I don't even want to know if they're anatomically correct. Kids remember everything you do wrong. So if you don't move the damn elf during the night there will be hell to pay. Because the elf would never go back to the same spot after running to the North Pole to be a tattle tale. They'll also remember that the elf was 2 inches to the right of the candle, and will know if someone touched it during the day.
I remember when my daughter came home from kindergarten and said that leprechauns leave candy in kid's shoes on St. Patrick's Day. Really. I guess it's a good thing she told me. I wanted her to believe in the wonderment so I kept putting candy in her smelly sneakers. One Christmas Eve she started crying while she looked at the refrigerator. "We have no carrots!" she sobbed. I had to convince her that reindeer get carrots at every other house and that too many make them gassy. So we should leave a salad instead so Santa wouldn't get farted on the whole trip (I know, I know, you don't have to say it). That worked for her. It also worked a few years later when we didn't have any milk and that Santa would like her best because she left him a beer (again, I know).
The first Christmas my daughter really understood Santa she asked for a Barbie horse. But it hadn't been on her list. Oh no, that would have been too easy. Instead she just told Santa. I asked her what she'd told him and fortunately she told me about the damn horse. She'd never mentioned this horse before, but that's what she wanted. And nobody had it. A stupid Barbie horse and nobody had it. I called every single store I could think of within an hour of my house. Found one 45 minutes away. So I drove there as fast as I could and when I got there it was the wrong color. But I got it anyway, hoping she'd forgotten which color she asked for. She had forgotten which color, along with the fact that she even wanted one. I think it was played with maybe twice.
As parents you'll do anything to keep the magic alive. Making footprints in the snow, leaving glitter behind, crumbs on the cookie plate, an empty beer bottle with a special note. The Easter Bunny was always a messy eater so there were carrot pieces all over the floor. But we want them to believe, to stay innocent for as long as they can. So why do we need some commercial product to take the place of the magic we can make ourselves?
Oh, and in case that's not enough there's now "The Elf on the Shelf: A Birthday Tradition". Consider yourself warned.











